Back in high school, 1996, when I was a senior at 17, I met a beautiful 15 year old girl. She had brown, curly hair, a pretty face, and great ass. Her name was Naomi and I wanted her for my own. I pursued and flirted with her everyday at school. After school, I would jerk off furiously, thinking about her opening her legs for me. I noticed she flirted with a lot of boys and there were rumors she was a slut.
As I asked around, I found out that her reputation came from a few angry girls, who's boyfriends had allowed Naomi to suck their cocks. From that point on, I would jerk off thinking about her lips wrapped around my cock. After I graduated, I turned 18 and she was 16. We finally started officially dating, despite her getting a couple of more cocks in her mouth from guys at school. One of the guys I couldn't stand, Ryan.
Ryan was a pretty boy who had four girls fighting over him, one of which was Naomi. I discovered years later that he learned to lick pussy from a book and word quickly spread among Naomi and other girls. They would suck his cock and swallow his cum, including Naomi, and he would return the favor by licking them to orgasm. I thought he was an asshole, and I felt good for taking Naomi away from him.
Our first date was at a Chinese restaurant and afterward, we went back to her place. She wrapped her lips around my cock for the first time and it was better than I could have imagined. I went down on her also, but I was clumsy and inexperienced. Later, Naomi would tell me that she faked an orgasm, because I was so bad. After dating for a month, Naomi opened her legs for me. Although she had sucked several cocks, she had never been fucked before. So we took each other's virginity. Later, she would tell me that she chose to fuck me, because out of the several cocks she had seen, mine was the largest. I'm not huge, just above average.
We fucked as often as we could. I would pick her up from school, we'd grab a bite to eat, and then we would go back to her house to fuck. She still sucked my cock and I still went down on her, but I still wasn't good at it. She faked her orgasms with me.
Then, after a couple more months, I found out that Naomi had been meeting Ryan in secret. He'd been going down on her and she'd been sucking his cock. Later, she would tell me that she would sometimes meet with him right before meeting up with me. When I confronted her, she apologized and then I learned the truth. She had gone to him, because he was good at making her orgasm and I was not. I told her that I forgave her, but not to fake orgasms again, or I would never improve. She agreed and thanked me for forgiving her. I steadily improved with her direction, but I would later learn that she cheated with Ryan twice more after our conversation.
A few months later, she would reveal to me that she had started dating another guy, while we were still dating. Naomi was involved in community theater and has met an attractive 24 year old named Rashawn, who worked as a stage hand. They had gone out once, but she didn't want to break up with me. He started flirting with her during community theater practice and he took her to lunch. I would learn later that they also went to his place, where they fucked.
She said she was confused and didn't know what to do about her attraction to both of us. I told her I understood and was determined to win her affection. So, I would take her out, watch movies with her, and take romantic walks. We still fucked as well, of course, and my pussy licking skills were continuing to improve. Every Friday, she would go out with Rashawn. Years later, she would admit that all they did on their dates was fuck. I would take her out to dinner and bring her flowers. Rashawn would pick her up and take her back to his place for sex. After their first lunch date, he wouldn't spend any more money on her. She would later tell me that I was a better boyfriend overall, but Rashawn had a bigger dick and was more skilled at fucking her. He was her first lover to make her orgasm from penetration, simething that I have never been able to do. She did admit I was better at oral though.
Many times she would cancel plans with me, because things would "come up." Only for me to learn later that she canceled on me to go get fucked by Rashawn. He was seeing other girls too, all teenage white girls from the community theater, but Naomi did not care. He treated her like a fuck toy. She would later tell me that her heart was mine, but her pussy was Rashawns. This arrangement, of Naomi having two boyfriends, lasted a year. Rashawn started calling her less and began canceling their hookups. Eventually, they drifted apart. She did ask about him and still occasionally saw him at community theater.
I felt that I had won. She was finally mine and when she turned 18, we moved into a one bedroom apartment. We fucked like rabbits that year and I proposed to her. She said yes. We arranged our wedding to take place before her twentieth birthday. She told me later that a month before our wedding, she ran into Rashawn again and told him that she was getting married. They flirted and eventually went to his apartment, where they fucked. This was the last time she saw him, but she never forgot how he filled and stretched her. She would later admit that if she ever ran into Rashawn again, she would have opened her legs for him.
Then, in the Spring, we were married.